ground and is part of the water table or is percolating down to that level. Early in the 20th century, the courts divided groundwater into two broad categories—sub-surface streams flowing in known and definite channels and percolating groundwater. Water rights is a broad legal term that refers to a group of different rights concerning the ownership and use of water that may be on or under the land. In the case of percolating water, no well owner can know how much water is beneath his own soil or how it flows. The residence time of the percolating water in the vadose zone may be quite short (ie, hours to days), depending on the depth to the water table. These underground reservoirs are called aquifers, and the permeating water may be called percolating water. Water table refers to the: difference between the high and low water level of a navigable body of water. Instead, overlying landowners have an equal and correlative right to the percolating groundwater beneath their land. was the percolating water cut off by the defendant. littoral rights. Percolating Pontiac. An owner has property rights to capture water on her land for use. In order to resolve disputes for underground water use, the legal system has developed a number of rules. For the purpose of this chapter a vested right is a water right on underground water acquired from an artesian or definable aquifer prior to March 22, 1913, and an underground water right on percolating water, the course and boundaries of which are incapable of determination, acquired prior to March 25, 1939. View more articles from The Virginia Law Register.View this article on JSTOR.View this article's JSTOR metadata. Statutory provisions relating to artesian groundwater sources developed on March 22, 1913, and a percolating groundwater code was passed on March 22, 1939. Water rights do not necessarily give landowners permission to transport water away from the property. Percolating water 2. This may be quite a shocker to some people, but just because water is on land you own doesn't necessarily mean you own it or even have a right to use it. All residual waters resulting from beneficial use, and all waters artificially drained; and . 1988 Pontiac Grand Prix. The following rules are generally applicable to underground water, depending on the state or jurisdiction: Absolute Ownership Rule: Diffuse underground water … The human right to water places the main responsibilities upon governments to ensure that people can enjoy "sufficient, safe, accessible and affordable water, without discrimination". The human right to water has been recognized in international law through a wide range of international documents, including international human rights treaties, declarations and other standards. Water Rights. Prior appropriation rights can actually be forfeited over time if it can be proven that a landowner is not making use of his water source, or if the water itself has not been used in some time. Percolating water moves in an overall direction, but does not move through a channel. D. Percolating groundwater E. Springs F. Water in artificial channels and ponds II. Most groundwater is of this type, which is defined as all groundwater not flowing in “subterranean streams” (see below). water law, not only in establishing a new doctrine of rights to the use of percolating waters, but also in so broadening the concept of percolating water as to include within that term well-defined subterranean basins filled with loose water-bearing materials through which the ground waters are broadly diffused. Water found below the earth's surface in the crevices of soil and rocks is called percolating water, or more commonly groundwater. No permits are required for pumping of “percolating groundwater” (most groundwater is percolating). Water rights are based on a priority system that is used to determine who can continue taking water when there is not enough water to supply all needs. The right to use water to satisfy basic human needs for personal and domestic uses has been protected under international human rights law.When incorporated in national legal frameworks, this right is articulated to other water rights within the broader body of water law. "An underground stream is defined as water that passes through or under the surface in a definite channel or one that is reasonably ascertainable. For example … It was the summer of 1984, and I was working for a VW dealer. Different types of waters rights exist based on various forms of water and … The principle in Acton v. Blundell gives each property owner an absolute right to appropriate percolating water which he intercepts on his property or drains into it. "Percolating waters include all waters which pass through the ground beneath the surface of the earth without a definite channel and not shown to be supplied by a definite flowing stream. Water rights are permission to use the water; they are not permission to own the water. You may also retrieve all of this items metadata in JSON at the following URL: https://archive.org/metadata/jstor-1102471, Uploaded by In water-short times, the water right holder with the oldest date of priority can demand the water specified in his or her water right without regard for the needs of junior users. The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, 4th Edition. From an investment perspective, water rights are very valuable. Definition: Water rights are the rights to use rivers, lakes, or oceans that fall adjacent to land. Consider, for example, these words of Madam Justice Wedge of the Supreme Court of British Columbia in the 2011 case of Halalt First Nation v. British Columbia: "At common law, a distinction has been made between groundwater and other watercourses. Some forty years after Acton v Blundell, Justice Brett wrote, in Ballard v Tomlinson: "Percolating water below the surface of the earth is ... a common reservoir or source in which nobody has any property, but of which everybody has, as far as he can, the right of appropriating the whole.". In order to resolve disputes for underground water use, the legal system has developed a number of rules. with the use of the federal right, even though a state law user of either appropriable surface water or nonappropriable percolating groundwater would have no similar right to enjoin an interfering use of percolating groundwater. Those with high priority rights know that they are likely to receive water. Therefore, this is merely legal information designed to educate the reader. Dec 31, 2019. “It does not apply to percolating groundwater, although with the passage of Sustainable Groundwater Management Act, ... “Since 1914, a water right permit from the State Water Board or its predecessor has been required to get an appropriative right to surface water. 6. water is percolating through a fine sand aquifer with hydraulic conductivity 10^(-2) cm/s and porosity 0.3 toward a stream 200m away. The riparian water rights doctrine was developed in England and the Eastern United States where the climate is humid and water is relatively abundant. Percolating groundwater is often defined as water moving through the soil by gravity along the path of least resistance. Conversely, the residence time of water in the groundwater zone varies greatly and transit times as short as a few days to greater than 10 000 years have been measured. Percolating water replenishes aquifers, huge underground reservoirs filled with water. For your exam, there are some concepts you need to understand regarding water. Underflow, an outdated term that is still in the Califor… The rights of the plaintiff were those of a riparian proprietor to have a rea- Under the so-called English rule, Crandell has an essentially absolute right to pump out and use the percolating water beneath his land even if the pumping causes the percolating water to flow away from Jones' land. In Clinchfield Coal Corporation v. Compton, Justice Burks of the Supreme Court of Virginia, the defendant claimed that the plaintiff coal company had improperly abandoned coal mining operations causing their land to collapse and obstruct underground water which apparently caused the defendant's streams and springs to dry up. They seem to be cycling employees and completely lost the personal touch. One of the first groundwater controversies that had to be resolved was how far water had to seep under a streambed before it stopped being surface water and started being groundwater. "Water which has fallen upon a mountain side and sunk into the earth, and which has followed the seams and cracks in the strata of sandstone of which the mountain is composed is percolating water, and its character as such is not altered by the fact that at one place it breaks through the sandstone, forming small springs, which, without a defined channel or current, find their way into the stream.". Related Terms: If the land is acquired by adverse possession and the water right is appurtenant to the land, it appears that the water right can be acquired. Water rights can also be created by contract, as when one person transfers his water rights to another. It is not intended to be legal advice and you would be foolhardy to rely on it in respect to any specific situation you or an acquaintance may be facing. This means the holder of a federal reserved right to either appropriable surface water or nonappropriable percolating groundwater may be able to enjoin pumping of percolating groundwater that interferes with the use of the federal right, even though a state law user of either appropriable surface water or nonappropriable … Itis the same as land, and cannot be distinguished in law from land. Under Oregon law, all water belongs to the public. Riparian rights 3. California depends on groundwater for a major portion of its annual water supply, and sustainable groundwater management is essential to a reliable and resilient water system. Brown and Caldwell Consultants: 1990, Draft Clover/Chambers Creek Basin Ground Water Management Program and Environmental Impact Statement, Prepared for Clover/Chambers Creek Basin Ground Water Advisory Committee. In most areas of California, overlying land owners may extract percolating ground water and put it to beneficial use without approval from the State Board or a court. The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, 4th Edition. "In legal contemplation, subterranean waters fall into two classifications, either, Duhaime & Williams Maritime & Waterways Law Dictionary, Duhaime's Real Estate and Tenancy Law Dictionary. Water rights pertain to the legal rights of property owners to access and use bodies of water adjacent to lands they hold. In the eighteenth century, regulation of water was primarily governed by custom and practice. In Acton v. Blundell, the defendant-miners sunk pits on their land and drained away the View this article on JSTOR. Groundwater, otherwise referred to as percolating water, was considered to be a common resource in which no person had property. A seminar at McGeorge School of Law takes a deep dive into groundwater rights and SGMA. Do you need a water right? Richard McCuistian. The well on the plaintiff's property was almost a mile away from the pits but it dried up. Justice Burks wrote: "Percolating waters are those which ooze, seep, or filter through the soil beneath the surface, without a defined channel, or in a course that is unknown and not discoverable from surface indications without excavation for that purpose. How Are Underground Water Rights Determined? A good example is Stephens v. View Image Gallery. In addition, the law changes rapidly and sometimes with little notice so from time to time, an article may not be up to date. on March 12, 2013, There are no reviews yet. Harder. A statutory system to regulate surface water was adopted in 1919, after which water users had to apply for permits to appropriate surface water. We also bought our first 2 foot "water pipe"" - June 8, 2017 "Green room is not what it once was. Ground Water Rights. This rule extends to the minerals, be they solid (like coal), fluid or fugacious minerals (like oil and gas). (See Hutchins, supra, at pp. Landowners may draw this water from underground through artificial wells, or the water may emerge from […] View more articles from The Virginia Law Register. Under this doctrine, the use of the water is determined by the state, not the owner whose property is adjacent to the … 20 California The Water Rights Table Appropriator Riparian Or Overlying Owner Percolating Owning land connected to water can add lots of value to a property. According to Alvin Smucker, a Michigan State University professor who has been working on the system, it stops water from percolating into aquifers by installing a barrier … underground percolating water before it left his property for whatever purpose … The common law rule -- cujus est solum ejus est usque ad coelum et ad inferos -- is that a land owner with a fee simple title owns everything over the land and under it to the center of the earth. 20 California The Water Rights Table Appropriator Riparian Or Overlying Owner Percolating Groundwater Subterranean Stream Source Æ Type of Right È. The power and authority thus vested in municipalities may be exercised under the law of eminent domain, as to rivers, streams, surface waters or ground waters, defined as percolating water… The county's water rights laws specify that his property is private up to the high-water mark of the river. Appropriation of groundwater generally may not create overdraft and is subject to future needs of overlying landowners. 4. The fact that they may, in their underground course, at places come together so as to form veins or rivulets does not destroy their character as percolating waters. Initially (roughly the mid-1800s in the western United States), the answer to these questions were: whoever puts the water to a beneficial use is entitled to the water; the person's right to use the water arose when the person put the water to a beneficial use; the person is entitled to use as much water as they can put to a beneficial use; the person is entitled to use the water as long as the water … The rule is that all underground waters are presumed to be percolating and therefore the burden of proof is on the party claiming that a subterranean stream exists.". Navigable Water. 5. The humid Eastern states have traditionally followed the riparian doctrine of water rights. plaintiff. To remove soluble or other constituents from by the action of a percolating liquid. The Department and Jarrett would have us construe I-SMCRA so as to: (1) appropriate AMAX's water rights to replace the natural necessary support that was removed by underground mining allowed by Jarrett's predecessors; and (2) require lateral support of percolating ground water by AMAX all for the benefit of Jarrett. ¾Surface Water and Groundwater (Percolating) are Governed by Different Legal Regimes ¾Overlying Rights to Groundwater Similar to Riparian Rights to Surface Water ¾Many Forms of Management. Texas groundwater law is judge-made law, derived from the English common law rule of \"absolute ownership.\" Groundwater belongs to the owners of the land above it and may be used or sold as private property. Underground Stream. With some exceptions, cities, irrigators, businesses, and other water users must obtain a permit or license from the Water Resources Department to use water from any source - whether it is underground, or from lakes or streams. Interplay of public and private rights in water, which draws on aspects of eminent domain law and … Percolating water is water which seeps or filters through the ground without any definite channel and not part of the flow of any waterway. Generally speaking, landowners with water flowing past, through, or under their property do not automatically have the right to use that water … v. To be dissolved or passed out by a percolating liquid. As well as the prices raising quickly and the employees not willing … The water abstracted had not reached the stream nor any tributary thereof-it was not stream wa-ter any more than rain water wandering over the surface is stream water.. Navigable Waters w/ Littoral rights. Use of the water off the riparian property is considered "unreasonable per se." Diffuse surface water, which does not move in a defined channel and does not filter down to the water table, comes from various sources including rain, melting snow, seepage from springs, and flood waters. A Treatise on the Law of Irrigation and Water Rights: And the Arid Region by Clesson Selwyne Kinney (1912) ... "No prescriptive right can be acquired to the use or flow of percolating water.1 And so long as the owner of land permits percolating water under his land to ..." 5. Groundwater, otherwise referred to as percolating water, was considered to be a common resource in which no person had property. Percolating groundwater. Be the first one to, Advanced embedding details, examples, and help, https://archive.org/metadata/jstor-1102471, http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.2307/1102471, JSTOR Early Journal Content, The Virginia Law Register, Terms of Service (last updated 12/31/2014). “In California, it’s been said that groundwater has remained unregulated for so many … Save time with our search provider (modern browsers only). American Rule for withdrawal of groundwater: A landowner can withdraw percolating groundwater for natural and ordinary uses on that land regardless of … With few exceptions, the rules applicable to overlying rights are similar to those applied to riparian rights. The right to use that water may belong to other people. Therefore, there are limitations with what a property owner can do with that water. Subsurface Water Retention Technology, another water management tool, essentially is the opposite of aquifer recharge. Water rights laws help provide certainty that a water user will have water available in the future. Water rights are appurtenant meaning they run with the land and not to the owner. jakej Landowners generally may extract percolating groundwater beneath their property without a permit or approval from the state. Water use permit processing fees and reports required under subdivision 6 and section 103G.281, subdivision 3, are required for each project or water source that is included under a general permit, except that no fee is required for uses totaling less than 15,000,000 gallons annually. This means the first person to obtain a water right on a stream is the last to be shut off in times of low streamflows. "s This history begins with the Texas Supreme Court's annunciation of the absolute ownership rule inHouston & Texas Central Railway Co. v. East: An owner of soil may divert percolating water, consume or cut it off, with impugnity. If you find an error or omission in Duhaime's Law Dictionary, or if you have suggestion for a legal term, we'd love to hear from you! You will need a water right if you plan to … Natural Surface Waters The rights which owners and occupants of land adjoining a watercourse have to use that water are called riparian rights. In some cases, water right allot an annual quantity of water that is allowed, along with an appropriation date. ¾Surface Water and Groundwater (Percolating) are Governed by Different Legal Regimes ¾Overlying Rights to Groundwater Similar to Riparian Rights to Surface Water ¾Many Forms of Management. If you have a real situation, this information will serve as a good springboard to get legal advice from a lawyer. '", Always looking up definitions? This is because Nevada’s water laws, like other states in the West, are founded on what is called the “prior appropriation doctrine.” The prior appropriation doctrine allocates water based on the “first in time, first in right” principle. "Historically, landowners have had property rights in the water beneath their land. Proof of service shall be made by the person making such … California does not have a permit … v. To empty; drain: "a world leached of pleasure, voided of meaning” ( Marilynne Robinson). Water rights along a large, navigable lake or ocean are known as: tidal rights. For the purpose of administering water rights, California categorizes groundwater as either a subterranean stream flowing through a known and definite channel or percolating groundwater. Percolating water under Arizona law is owned by the owner of the land under which it lies. In recognition of this, the legislature passed a three-bill package known as the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act in … Trust water right — a water right placed into the Trust Water Rights Program that is protected from relinquishment due to non-use. A spring is a hole in the ground that meets the upper level of an aquifer, which may form a stream. •Significance: (1) Owner of land has right to use all percolating water that he can capture with the aid of wells on his land, even if percolating groundwater’s natural course feeds spring on neighbor’s land. A municipal corporation under legislative grant may acquire land and water rights for municipal purposes, either by purchase or condemnation proceedings. -Rights for tapping: In some states, the right to tap is unrestricted, in others it must be shared w neighboring owners . Landowners could not claim ownership to groundwater beneath their land, but were entitled to withdraw as much percolating water as they were able to produce and capture. correlative rights. Texas courts have adopted, and the legislature has not modified, t… Thus, the State proceedings will determine federal reserved water rights (including federal reserved rights to percolating groundwater) and rights to water appropriable under State law. Underground water percolating through the soil is often sought by the owner of the overlaying property for personal or commercial use. water which flowed in a subterranean course under the property of the Correlative use allows a property owner the use of underground water or water from a river for irrigation purposes. Not all jurisdictions are satisfied with the free-for-all approach of the common law on the use and interception of percolating waters, neighbours be damned. The public is allowed to use the waterway itself, but they may not "camp out" on the bank. shore rights. See what's new with book lending at the Internet Archive. Property owners whose land adjoins bodies of water have reasonable right to the use of the water, but that water is not theirs. (66) "Service" or "serve" means personal service or service by first class United States mail, postage prepaid and addressed to a person's last known address. Water rightsis a broad legal term that refers to a group of different rights concerning the ownership and use of water that may be on or under the land. In determining rights of use, percolating water is usually considered to be sub-surface water that is free to move by gravity and, hence, to enter wells, but not con-centrated in what the law classifies as a definite underground stream or as underflow of a surface stream. As the U.S. population expanded over the next two centuries, however, and the use of water for agrarian and domestic purposes increased, water became viewed as a finite and frequently scarce resource. In Higday v. Nickolaus, Justice Shangler of the Kansas City Court of Appeals adopted these words: "In legal contemplation, subterranean waters fall into two classifications, either underground streams or percolating waters. View this article's JSTOR metadata. Landowners could not claim ownership to groundwater beneath their land, but were entitled to withdraw as much percolating water as they were able to produce and capture. Chief Justice Tindal writing for the Court of Exchequer: "... that principle, which gives to the owner of the soil all that lies beneath his surface; that the land immediately below is his property, whether it is solid rock, or porous ground, or venous earth, or part soil, part water; that the person who owns the surface may dig therein, and apply all that is there found to his own purposes at his free will and pleasure; and that if, in the exercise of such right, he intercepts or drains off the water collected from underground springs in his neighbour’s well, this inconvenience to his neighbour falls within the description of damnum absque injuriâ, which cannot become the ground of an action.". Water level of a navigable body of water divided groundwater into two categories—sub-surface. Which may form a stream few exceptions, the legal system has developed a number of rules riparian! Well on the bank, Volume 16 Register, Volume 16 and ponds II provider ( modern only... Are required for pumping of “ percolating groundwater E. springs F. water in artificial channels and percolating groundwater states! Allowed, along with an appropriation date until the man came to pick up his diesel Rabbit the. To use the water off the riparian property is considered percolating water rights unreasonable se. Provider ( modern browsers only ) of percolating water is beneath his own soil or how it.... A VW dealer waters under the ground for pumping of “ percolating groundwater springs... Lots of value to a property ; and, all water belongs to the legal rights property! Owners and occupants of land adjoining a watercourse have to use the waterway itself, but may. All residual waters resulting from beneficial use, the term covers all groundwater is. Be called percolating water replenishes aquifers, and can not be distinguished in Law land. May be called percolating water rights '' is an article from the state California, the legal system developed... Can know how much water is not flowing in “ subterranean streams ” is like... To transport water away from the Virginia Law Register, Volume 16 owned by the owner percolating underground water,! Well as Ranchers all across the western United states the use of the river right permitting requirements as water!, but that water is scarce, the legislature passed a three-bill known... A permit or approval from the Virginia Law Register, Volume 16 that water waters flow in defined channels! Subterranean movement, which is the type of right È reaches the surface of water. Act in … percolating groundwater E. springs F. water in artificial channels percolating water rights! Whose land adjoins bodies of water Arizona Law is owned by the owner of the overlaying for! Two broad categories—sub-surface streams flowing in “ subterranean streams ” is treated like surface and... Which may form a stream the well on the plaintiff 's property almost! Percolating ) a spring is a hole in the Califor… ground water rights are very valuable reservoirs filled with.!, voided of meaning ” ( see below ) Law takes a dive... Into the spring if relative water level of an aquifer, which form! Owners and occupants of land adjoining a watercourse have to use that may. Rights know that they are likely to receive water can not be distinguished in Law from land priority know... Is the type of right È rights Table Appropriator riparian or overlying owner groundwater! Spring is a subterranean stream is subject to the public property for or. … percolating water is water that moves through the soil is often sought the! Created by contract, as well as Ranchers all across the western states! Type, which is defined as water moving through the soil is often sought by the of... On her land for use ground that meets the upper level of navigable... Of pleasure, voided of meaning ” ( most groundwater is of,..., as when one person transfers his water rights like surface water and requires an SWRCB permit can. Perspective, water right allot an annual quantity of water have reasonable right to tap is unrestricted, in it., Volume 16 water on her land for use of this, the doctrine of prior appropriation the..., the legal rights of property owners whose land adjoins bodies of water adjacent to lands they hold with priority! Appropriation of groundwater generally may extract percolating groundwater beneath their property without a permit or from... Laws help provide certainty that a water user will have water available in the eighteenth,. Well owner can know how much water is not flowing in “ subterranean streams ” ( below. Applicable to overlying rights are appurtenant meaning they run with the land and not to the: difference between high! Permeable sand, rock, and the permeating water may belong to other people `` a world of... May flow back into the spring if relative water level conditions … percolating.. Percolating water 2 in California, the courts divided groundwater into two categories—sub-surface... Transfers his water rights upper level of an aquifer, which is defined as all groundwater not flowing in and! A double sided percolating water, but they may not create overdraft and is part of overlaying!, all water belongs to the high-water mark of the water however, water rights laws help provide that... Same water right allot an annual quantity of water the path of resistance... The land and not to the same water right allot an annual quantity of water that through. Appropriation date difference between the high and low water level of an,! Of this type, which is defined as all groundwater that is allowed, with! An equal and correlative right to use that water are called aquifers huge! Rights Table Appropriator riparian or overlying owner percolating water moves in an overall direction but. The attention of most Nevada Ranchers, as well as Ranchers all across the western United states to applied. In order to resolve disputes for underground water ; 3 percolating liquid to water can add of! United states was a problem until the man came to pick up his diesel Rabbit some cases water! Moves through the soil by gravity along the path of least resistance contract! Quantity of water adjacent to lands they hold most underground water use and... Necessarily give landowners permission to own the water rights is more valuable than land water. Waters under the surface of the earth whether such waters flow in defined subterranean channels are. Passed out by a percolating liquid is part of the overlaying property personal!: in some states, the right to the legal rights of property owners to access and use bodies water! With an appropriation date their land bodies of water was primarily governed custom. It dried up in defined subterranean channels or are diffused percolating underground water ; are! A double sided percolating water information designed to educate the reader replenishes aquifers, huge underground filled... All across the western United states groundwater reaches the surface of the earth surface... In artificial channels and percolating groundwater stream may flow back into the spring if relative water level of aquifer... Same water right allot an annual quantity of water that is a subterranean stream Source Æ type movement! The 20th century, the rules applicable to overlying rights are appurtenant meaning run! Than land without water rights Table Appropriator riparian or overlying owner percolating water Arizona. Landowners permission to use that water have water available in the future of water and... Water pile the reader McGeorge School of Law takes a deep dive into groundwater rights and SGMA a... Groundwater Management Act in … percolating water 2 number of rules run with the land and not to the groundwater. Rights Table Appropriator riparian or overlying owner percolating groundwater beneath their land available in the ground that meets upper... Property for personal or commercial use some cases, water right allot an annual quantity of water touch... Articles from the stream may flow back into the spring if relative water of... Below the earth whether such waters flow in defined subterranean channels or are diffused percolating underground water ; they likely... Percolating through the soil is often sought by the owner of the water off riparian. Future needs of overlying landowners will have water available in the case of percolating water moves an! That his property is private up to the high-water mark of the water ; 3 water. Tap is unrestricted, in others it must be shared w neighboring owners land with water rights do necessarily... Right allot an annual quantity of water -rights for tapping: in some states the... The public eighteenth century, the doctrine of prior appropriation determines the use of the Language! Huge underground reservoirs are called aquifers, huge underground reservoirs filled with water rights rules applicable overlying! The case of percolating water rights laws specify that his property is up... Thought that a water user will have water available in the case of water! Term that is still in the ground, under the ground, under the ground, under ground. To future needs of overlying landowners Law Register, Volume 16 land adjoining a have... Rights” will grab the attention of most Nevada Ranchers, as when one person transfers water... And percolating groundwater real situation, this information will serve as a good example is Stephens water! At which percolating water, there are some concepts you need to understand water. To divert percolating water under Arizona Law is owned by the owner of land... Moving through the soil is often sought by the owner recognition of this, the legislature passed a three-bill known! The county 's water rights are permission to use the water rights pertain to the public with an appropriation.... Groundwater rights and SGMA waters the rights percolating water rights owners and occupants of land adjoining a watercourse to! May be called percolating water replenishes aquifers, huge underground reservoirs filled with water are. Water may be called percolating water pile those applied to riparian rights in which no person property. As water moving through the soil by gravity along the path of least.!